HIST 100: Engineering The Past

  • Home
  • Syllabus
  • Schedule
  • Blog

Tohono O’odham Nation

March 12, 2016 by kaleobbusmann 3 Comments

The Tohono O’odham Nation has been treated unfairly since the Gadsden purchase of 1853. Their land was cut in half when the U.S. and Mexico border was created, and were forced onto a reservation after violently getting pushed out of Mexico. Ranchers began taking up the Southern Arizona grasslands to feed their cattle and directly competing with the O’odham farmers. Armed conflicts constantly occurred with Mexican citizens and the Tohono tribe, on the U.S. border farmers constantly complained about the Tohono cutting their fences.

The Tohono O’odham Nation was eventually granted three million acres to the West of Tucson, Arizona. After facing constant adversity the people of the Tohono O’odham Nation were able preserve their traditions and gatherings while building up a community. The Tohono O’odham Nation were able to create their own sovereign government, but in the mid-1980s tribal lawyers discovered the Winters Doctrine that gave the tribe most of the groundwater in the Santa Cruz Valley. The city of Tuscon relied heavily on well water and constantly bought farmland to get access to more groundwater. Eventually the federal government gave the Tohono O’odham Nation thousands of acres feet of water from the Central Arizona Project.

Ethically speaking, I do not believe the Tohono O’odham tribe was completely compensated for their losses when the U.S. annexed their land in the Gadsden purchase. I think they were fairly treated when they received three million acres dedicated to them. I believe the U.S. government also severely hindered the ability of the Tohono O’odham to establish a stable community. Ranchers constantly allowed cattle to graze on their lands, they received little help when being constantly raided by Apache warriors and also by Mexican citizens.

Filed Under: 09.1 Natives and Water Rights, Group 2

8.2 Middle Eastern Woes

March 5, 2016 by petewcook 1 Comment

Hey y’all Pete here. In Pakistan they use the Moslem water principles at the local level in order to allocate and distribute water to agricultural users. They still use the British Canal and Drainage Act of 1873 as a rule of law when it comes to the governmental level, where water management is a provincial matter, in three of the four provinces. This is one of the world’s oldest and largest irrigation systems and it has been suffering from decay for the past 50-80 years. Salinity is damaging crop production to thousands of acres of land every year. The main problem they have is at the farm level there is improper management and also lack of coordination between the provinces.

If I could rewind time, traveling back to the past to advise Middle Eastern leaders about water resources, here is what I would advise them to do. I would tell them that they need to create a better administrative system which would be comprised of tribunals of irrigators in each irrigation community, like that of Valencia, Spain. This would help to narrow and pinpoint the decision making when it came to deciding on what should be done about water allocation and distribution. The meetings and decisions of these tribunals should be public and verbal, with the decisions being made being written down and recorded in a record book. This would make the system simple and equal. The problem of inequality and social classes battling against the actual people who need the irrigation would almost cease to exist and the change would help to prevent it from happening in the future. I would keep the water structures, such as the qanats and waterways, the same because they already go to where they need to, but I would add some norias, or water wheels, along with more tanks so that when a drought came, some water would be stored for future use.

I believe these leaders would think that these ideas would be worth implementing because they are simple, they bring more equality to the irrigation community, which would result in greater efficiency and production, and it would create a much better system since the people who use the water would actually be in charge of it. They know how much water they need and how to disperse it across the land better than the ruling elite, so it makes a lot of sense to hand them the power that they deserve.

The first piece of information that I would need from the past in order to write a formal research paper about my recommendations is who the exact ruler(s) were during the time period that I choose. The second piece of information that I would need is what time period I would be researching. The third piece of information that I would need is some of the actual laws that were written and implemented during that time period and by those rulers. I would look for this information on the past either a) the Academic Search Premier, b) Albertson’s or Boise Public Library, or c) A credible internet source such as an article that is scholarly or peer-reviewed.

Pete

Filed Under: 08.2: Middle Eastern water woes, Group 2

Middle eastern water woes

March 5, 2016 by indeabennett 1 Comment

draft

If you could rewind time, traveling back to the past to advise Middle Eastern leaders about water resources,

what would you advise them to do? Be specific;

name the country or countries you are talking about, and reference particular engineered structures and systems. What would you keep the same, and

what would you recommend they do differently?

Based on what little you have learned from course readings of the various cultures in the region and the political situations there, do you think the leaders would view your recommendations as worth implementing? Explain your reasoning.

The middle east is already a place were people have to adapt to survive there well, water is a crucial part in being able to survive in these difficult climates. From the inception of the countries water conversations should have been one of the most important focuses. instead many

(insert examples of countries here) water reserves have been used till they dried up or contaminated leaving farmers with out the abilities to maintain crops and cities with out the means to live.

(insert engineered structures/systems that cause this)

(what would you keep the same?/how would you change the problem?)

More info. needed:

(Where would you look to find this information about the past? Again, be as specific as possible.)

– what were past regional weather patterns like? what is the norm for the area’s ?

– population growth and how it attributed to the rate of water consumption both for people and use

-historically what other methods have been used for water ? were they more effective than the systems that lead to the current water state?

Filed Under: 08.2: Middle Eastern water woes, Group 2

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • …
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • …
  • 21
  • Next Page »

Students

Log in here.

Groups

Student Contributions

From the Professor

Copyright © 2026 · Minimum Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in